Manfred says MLB owners won't sign a labor deal without a salary cap and floor
With the labor contract expiring Dec. 1, the commissioner called the union's refusal to discuss a cap a refusal to bargain. The players say the plan would cut their pay.

Major League Baseball owners will not sign a new labor contract unless it includes a salary cap and a payroll floor, Commissioner Rob Manfred said Wednesday. That position all but guarantees a lockout when the current agreement runs out and puts the 2027 season in doubt.
Manfred spoke on the second day of the owners meetings in Manhattan. He said the sessions there dealt "almost exclusively" with labor. The collective bargaining agreement with the MLB Players Association expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on Dec. 1, and owners are expected to lock players out once it does. That would be the sport's 10th work stoppage since 1972.
Manfred said he was open to compromise on other issues but not on this one, and he framed the cap as something the public is asking for. "They want salary cap and floor, and on that, we will not compromise," he said.
Calling it the fans' demand looks like shrewd positioning. It also seems an odd fit with what fans have actually lost in past fights between these two sides. The last time owners formally put a cap on the table, in 1994, players struck for more than seven months, and the World Series was canceled for the first time in 90 years. Manfred was a junior lawyer on the owners' bargaining team that year, so that history is hardly abstract to him.
The players have called a cap a "nonstarter," and Manfred went after that word directly. "Another word for 'nonstarter' over months is a refusal to bargain," he said. He said the league first made its proposal in May. He added that the union does not have to accept it as written, but it should look for ways to meet in the middle rather than offer nothing in return.
What the league is proposing
Before Manfred spoke, Morgan Sword, MLB's executive vice president of baseball economics and operations, walked reporters through the plan. Its main terms:
- 2027: The current economic system would stay in place for one more season.
- 2028 cap: A hard cap of $258.2 million.
- 2028 floor: A minimum payroll of $180.2 million. A team could drop as low as 90% of the floor, or $162.18 million, in a given year, but it would have to spend the full floor amount over a three-year period.
- Contracts: Individual player contracts would also have a cap.
- Revenue: The league says players would get a 50-50 share of revenue.
Manfred insisted a cap-and-floor system "is the best way" to share local media revenue equally among teams. In the league's telling, that sharing would allow MLB to end local blackouts as money from regional sports networks keeps shrinking in most markets.
The blackout pitch may be the league's strongest public argument, because it promises a concrete benefit that fans would notice right away. The union's reply seems hard to dismiss, too. It says MLB created the blackout problem and could solve it without tying the solution to player pay. Linking a broadcast fix to a pay restructuring looks like a bargaining tactic, and players have every reason to treat it as one.
Why the union won't move
Bruce Meyer, the union's interim executive director, responded in a statement released after Manfred's news conference. He said the owners' refusal to negotiate on economics outside of a cap shows the league is not serious about bargaining. In his view, the system would sharply lower pay for every category of player and take away rights such as fully guaranteed contracts.
He was blunt about why he thinks the owners want it. "They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries," Meyer said.
The union also argues the math does not work the way the league says. Its objection to the 50-50 split is that the calculation leaves out roughly $400 million in amateur signing bonuses, which would cut total player compensation right away. The players also dispute how the owners count revenue and expenses.
That accounting dispute may matter more than the cap itself. A 50-50 split sounds even until both sides argue over what goes into the revenue pool. Football, basketball and hockey all run some version of a cap. Baseball's union has resisted one for decades, and it lost a full postseason in 1994 rather than accept one. It is hard to see it changing course for a proposal it believes starts below what players earn now.
What a lockout would freeze
Once a lockout starts, all contact between clubs and players on 40-man rosters stops. Trades and signings stop too. A lockout beginning in early December would freeze the offseason trade and free agent market in the middle of the period when teams usually build their rosters.
Manfred did not commit to locking players out the moment the contract expires. "A decision on a lockout is one that we're going to make at the last possible moment," he said. He added that he is "not that big on Thanksgiving as a holiday." He said the league would bargain wherever and whenever needed in the remaining time.
The last stoppage followed a similar pattern. Owners locked out players in December 2021, and that lockout pushed back the start of the 2022 season. An offseason lockout does not cost games right away, which gives both sides room to wait each other out. That room disappears as spring training gets closer.
The league's own proposal shows some flexibility on timing. Keeping the current system for 2027 and starting the cap in 2028 gives the league a transition year to offer. That suggests owners know a cap cannot be imposed overnight. The flexibility ends there, though. Manfred said he could not picture the owners approving any deal without the cap and floor.
For now, the two sides disagree about the basic structure of baseball's economics, not about numbers within an agreed framework. With about two weeks left before the deadline, nothing in either side's public statements points to an early settlement. Neither side has offered a reason to expect one before Dec. 1.




