Search
Sports

Hutchinson out for season, Maye feared to have broken ankle after one Munich sack

The Lions lose their star pass rusher to a torn ACL. The Patriots now face a playoff chase with Tommy DeVito at quarterback and a brutal late schedule.

Aidan Hutchinson in a blue Detroit Lions No. 97 jersey with eye black, seated on the sideline.
File photo. Photo: All-Pro Reels / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Key Takeaways

  • Aidan Hutchinson tore his right ACL and may also have meniscus damage, sources told NFL Network
  • The Patriots fear Drake Maye fractured his right ankle, and he could miss the rest of the season
  • Mike Vrabel said he does not expect to look outside the organization for a quarterback
  • The league said the tackle was not an illegal hip-drop, and no penalty was called

A single snap in Munich may have cost two contenders their most important players. Detroit Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson tore the ACL in his right knee while celebrating a first-quarter sack Sunday and will miss the rest of the season, sources told NFL Network's Ian Rapoport. The quarterback he brought down, New England's Drake Maye, is feared to have fractured his right ankle on the same play.

Rapoport also reported concern that Hutchinson damaged the meniscus in the injured knee. Hutchinson had an initial MRI in Germany and is scheduled for more testing now that he is back in the United States. Maye stayed behind in Germany. Sources told ESPN's Adam Schefter that the Patriots are worried about a break, and both Schefter and Rapoport reported that Maye will be out for an extended period that could stretch through the end of the season.

Detroit won the game 35-10 at Allianz Arena. Few teams have taken a lopsided win that felt this expensive.

A legal hit with a brutal cost

The play came on third down during New England's opening possession. Hutchinson chased Maye from behind, wrapped his right arm around the quarterback's right shoulder pad and dragged him to the turf, landing on Maye's lower leg. Hutchinson then jumped to celebrate, came down hard and collapsed, grabbing his right knee right away.

He eventually walked to the blue medical tent, then made a slow trip to the locker room and did not return. After the game he left the stadium on crutches. Maye needed help getting up, limped to the sideline and later went to the locker room for evaluation. He had completed 3 of 4 passes for 48 yards before the injury. Tommy DeVito took over on the next series.

Because the sack looked at first like it might be a hip-drop tackle, which the NFL banned before the 2024 season, the officiating question came up immediately. Fox rules analyst Mike Pereira said on the broadcast that it did not meet the definition. An illegal hip-drop requires the tackler to unweight himself, swivel and land on the back of the runner's leg below the knee, he explained, and Hutchinson did not do that. "This was more of a horse collar-type pulled down from behind," Pereira said, adding that it was not a horse collar penalty either.

Walt Anderson, the NFL's officiating rules analyst, backed that reading through a league spokesman, noting the absence of any swivel or unweighting. Because Hutchinson grabbed neither the collar nor the nameplate, a horse collar foul did not apply. Referee Clay Martin's crew threw no flag.

Patriots coach Mike Vrabel declined to fault the defender. "However it happened, I don't think it was anything intentional. It's just part of the game," he said.

Under the current rules, that is the correct call, and Vrabel's response took the heat out of a play that could easily have become a grievance. Still, it is a grim result when a technically clean tackle sidelines a franchise quarterback and the celebration afterward ends the tackler's season.

Detroit loses its best pass rusher again

Hutchinson has six sacks this season, second on the Lions, and 49 in his career since Detroit took him second overall in the 2022 draft. He is a two-time Pro Bowler. This is also the second time in three seasons that a major injury has cut his year short. He broke his leg in October 2024, when he was among the league's top pass rushers.

Coach Dan Campbell had little to add after the game, before the extent of the injury was known. "Nothing new. We'll know more when we get back in the States," he said.

Detroit can generate pressure in other ways, but Hutchinson is the edge rusher that opposing offenses build their protection plans around. Losing him changes how every remaining opponent can block the Lions. That cost will show up in quarterbacks getting an extra half-second, not in a single statistic. Detroit's ability to win games late and in January depends heavily on how well the rest of the front can make up for that lost time.

New England's quarterback problem

Speaking Monday, Vrabel would not discuss the specifics of Maye's injury or a possible return date, saying he wanted to wait until the quarterback got back from Germany. In an interview with Boston radio station WEEI, he said Maye stayed overseas "just out of caution." He also said he did not expect Maye to play in Week 12, when New England comes off its bye to face the Los Angeles Chargers.

Vrabel indicated the Patriots will stay in-house at quarterback for now. Asked about bringing in an outside replacement, he said, "I don't see that being the case right now." DeVito is the starter. The roster also includes rookie Behren Morton, a seventh-round pick from Texas Tech. ESPN noted the team could add another passer, possibly to the practice squad.

DeVito's first outing did not inspire much confidence. He went 12-of-24 for 81 yards with a touchdown and an interception against Detroit. His run as a fill-in starter with the Giants made him a fan favorite, but there is a big gap between a feel-good story and an offense that can win in December. Standing pat is a bet that the defense and running game can carry more of the load. The bye week gives Vrabel's staff extra time to shape a plan around DeVito, but those numbers suggest the margin for error just got much thinner.

The injury also interrupts what had been a turnaround for Maye. Over a 1-2 start, he threw one touchdown pass against six interceptions. He followed that with 14 touchdowns and two picks over his next five games, then threw three interceptions in last week's loss to the Packers. The runner-up for MVP in 2025, he had started 43 consecutive games including the playoffs. Among NFL quarterbacks, only Buffalo's Josh Allen, at 146, and Detroit's Jared Goff, at 82, have longer streaks.

The standings leave little room. According to Fox Sports, New England is one game behind the Cleveland Browns for the AFC's last wild-card spot. The schedule ahead includes the Bills, Vikings, Chiefs and Broncos, all ranked in the top six of Fox analyst Bucky Brooks' power rankings. That is a tough finish with a healthy Maye and an alarming one without him.

Sunday's damage extended beyond the quarterback. Wide receiver A.J. Brown, playing his first game after missing two with a knee injury, left in the fourth quarter with a hamstring injury. "We'll see what the severity of that is once we get back and kind of go from there," Vrabel said. If DeVito also has to start without one of his most dangerous targets, the Chargers game will be a hard test of how much this offense can absorb.

Sources

Maya Carter

Maya Carter covers track and field, major competitions, and the performances that shape each season. Her coverage connects results with event formats, qualification routes, and the wider sporting calendar. She focuses on clear explanations of records, rankings, and race developments, helping readers follow the stories beyond the finish line.

View all stories