Search
Entertainment

Pattinson's Bond casting trades mystery for star power, and the reaction is split

George Lazenby welcomed the new 007, Bond screenwriters cheered, and some in the industry argued the role should have gone to a lesser-known actor.

Robert Pattinson in a black leather jacket at a red carpet event with blurred lights behind him.
File photo. Photo: Harald Krichel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Robert Pattinson had barely been named the next James Bond when the industry started arguing about him. The fight is not over whether he can act. It is over whether a 40-year-old who already plays Batman should be the face of a franchise that has usually made its stars rather than borrowed them.

Amazon MGM Studios announced early Monday that Pattinson will play 007 in the reboot Denis Villeneuve is directing. Within hours, a former Bond had welcomed him, two longtime Bond screenwriters had praised the pick, and anonymous agents had called it a safe, predictable choice.

George Lazenby, who played Bond once, in 1969's On Her Majesty's Secret Service, posted a message to his successor on social media. "Robert, welcome to the most exclusive club in the world. But remember to enjoy yourself," he wrote. He also joked that Pattinson might get his own version of the famous line Lazenby's Bond delivers to the camera in that film, "This never happened to the other fella."

Who's making the new Bond

Pattinson will be the first 007 under Amazon MGM, which now owns the franchise. Steven Knight, who created Peaky Blinders, wrote the script. Amy Pascal and David Heyman are producing, and Tanya Lapointe is an executive producer. Deadline reports that the film is in pre-production.

Pattinson takes over from Daniel Craig, whose run ended with 2021's No Time to Die. Reported finalists for the part included Callum Turner, Jack Lowden, Josh O'Connor and Nicholas Hoult. Villeneuve opened his statement by thanking them before turning to the winner. "He has the timeless soul of 007 and brings a spirit that is completely new," the director said.

Pattinson's statement called the role "the honor of a lifetime" and thanked Villeneuve, Pascal, Heyman, Lapointe and the studio by name.

How he got there is its own story. TheWrap reported that Pattinson joined the search late but quickly looked like the favorite, helped by having just worked with Villeneuve on Dune: Part Three. Deadline columnist Baz Bamigboye offered a less tidy version. He wrote that none of the actors who screen-tested seemed right and that, by his account, the studio and others involved panicked. At that point Villeneuve asked to see Pattinson perform the From Russia with Love scene that every Bond hopeful must play. IGN, citing reports, said Pattinson was offered a more lucrative contract for fewer films than the other contenders.

The case for and against a movie star

The core complaint is simple. TheWrap noted that Sean Connery, Lazenby, Timothy Dalton and Craig were all largely unknown when they were cast. Pascal and Heyman, the outlet reported, set out to go younger, with a Bond fresh out of the Navy. They ended up with an actor who has had major roles in four films this year alone.

One top agent told TheWrap that young audiences' central complaint is that "the same actors are cast over and over again," and that the choice makes things feel homogeneous and safe. Another agent said the casting "isn't smart" because Bond has never needed a star. "The role is the star," that agent said. A movie-world acquaintance of Bamigboye's who has long lived in Britain made the same point, he wrote: "Bond creates the stars. The stars don't create Bond."

Bamigboye shares some of that doubt. He wrote that he expects Pattinson to be good, though casting a 40-year-old movie star hardly feels fresh. He also worries that Batman baggage will color how audiences see him as Bond. That concern has a practical side. Bamigboye reported that Pattinson left a Sunday-night screening of Primetime early because he had an early call on The Batman: Part II. Juggling two franchises built on brooding heroes looks like a branding problem as much as a scheduling one.

The other camp includes people who have actually written Bond. Robert Wade and Neil Purvis, who worked on several films under Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson, told Deadline that Pattinson is "a terrific choice, very exciting." They said they liked "the sly wit he brought to the spy in Tenet," and read the casting as a sign that Villeneuve wants to keep Bond cool. A studio executive who spoke to TheWrap went further: "Perfect choice!"

Matthew Vaughn, whose Layer Cake helped persuade Broccoli to back Craig, gave Deadline a one-line brush-off. "When I last checked Bond is dead. Long live The Kingsman," he said.

Why the star argument is weaker than it sounds

The "unknowns only" argument looks like a selective reading of the franchise's history. Roger Moore was already a familiar television star from The Saint when he took over. Pierce Brosnan was known to American audiences from Remington Steele. Bond has survived recognizable leads before. What sets Pattinson apart is that his fame comes from film franchises that are still running, which is why the Batman overlap seems to matter more than the fame itself.

His track record also undercuts the idea that this is a timid, corporate pick. After Twilight, Pattinson spent years in projects that likely got made only because he signed on: David Cronenberg's Cosmopolis, the Safdie brothers' Good Time, Claire Denis' High Life and Robert Eggers' The Lighthouse. When he did return to blockbusters, he chose directors with strong voices. He played Neil in Christopher Nolan's Tenet and led Matt Reeves' The Batman, which took in $772.3 million worldwide. This year he appeared in Nolan's The Odyssey, the A24 romance The Drama and Primetime, in which he plays former Dateline correspondent Chris Hansen.

That mix of studio size and oddball instincts looks like exactly what a Villeneuve Bond would want. It also looks like a smart hedge for Amazon, which has to show it can run a franchise it paid dearly to control. A bankable name offers some insurance against a flop. The agents may well be right about the larger trend: Hollywood keeps handing its biggest properties to the same small group of actors instead of building new ones. Even so, that critique says more about the industry than about whether Pattinson fits this role.

The most revealing comment may be his own. In a 2012 interview with the U.K. publication Shortlist, Pattinson said he would "definitely" want the part, but more like 20 years later. "I think there'd be nothing worse than, like, 'Let's get a fresh-faced Bond!'" he said. "After Daniel Craig, you have to have some baggage." Fourteen years on, the baggage he described is the main objection to his casting, and the main thing he brings to it.

Audiences will see Pattinson next in Dune: Part Three in December, playing a villain for the director who will now oversee his Bond.

Sources

Nina Patel

Nina Patel covers film, from release announcements and festival lineups to the changing ways audiences watch movies. Her coverage follows upcoming titles, production developments, and the wider conversation around cinema. She pays attention to release details and creative context, helping readers navigate a crowded calendar of films and screen events.

View all stories